Public teacher in a public hospital

An educator's trip to the ER reveals an unpleasant truth about our city's budget


By Sasha Cuttler

OPINION San Francisco Unified School District teachers and Department of Public Health nurses are going through difficult times. Despite years of service reductions, layoffs, and ceaseless budget pressures, teachers continue to educate San Francisco's young people while nurses care for the sick and injured.

One week before the end of this school year, Balboa High School math teacher Ruth Radetsky was found unconscious after flying over the handlebars of her bicycle. She was brought to San Francisco General Hospital and Trauma Center, where she was treated for broken ribs, scapula, and cracked vertebrae. Although she suffered a concussion, she avoided a more severe head injury because she wore her bicycle helmet.

After being stabilized in intensive care unit and transferred to the step-down unit, Ruth was instructed by nurses to call for help before trying to get up. She was afraid of the pain but understood the importance of regaining mobility. Her injuries and the side effects of the pain medication put her at high risk for falling. Noting how busy the nurses were, however, Ruth felt badly about having to "bother" the staff.

Ruth and the nurses at SFGH who cared for her have a lot in common. Both education and health care rely upon appropriate ratios: teachers to students and nurses to patients. Students and patients alike benefit from these ratios. Despite the need for enough human resources, adequate staffing depends on other factors as well.

Ruth explained how a reduced class size is not enough. In one of her classes, nearly half of the students had learning needs that required preferential seating. Not everyone can sit in the front seat. Nurses with a floor full of patients who need close observation because they are experiencing delirium tremens, traumatic brain injury, or even a mass casualty event have to do similar triage. In both cases, maintaining the minimum staffing may be inadequate — which is why nurses and teachers need support to achieve quality education and healthcare. And UCLA researchers have demonstrated that lower nursing staffing in hospital wards is associated with increased patient mortality.

While researchers argue about the effect of increased class size and nurse-patient ratios, teachers and nurses in the public sector struggle to maintain professional standards of education and care. Ruth is worried about the effects of teacher layoffs on her students. At the same time, the nurses who cared for her at San Francisco General Hospital are being told that layoffs could result if wages and benefits and staffing aren't reduced. In both professions, staff is concerned about maintaining adequate services with fewer resources.

Teachers and nurses in the public sector continue to be predominately female. Perhaps because of traditional gender roles, teachers and nurses tend to be apologetic about taking a stand for their own working conditions. Unlike an assembly line worker, a teacher or nurse's profession is all about people, not things. It is only logical that too many students make it difficult for each to receive the amount of support needed. It's dangerous for nurses to not have enough time for patient assessment and care.

Teachers such as Ruth Radetsky and the nurses who cared for her embody the very best of public education and health. San Francisco Unified teachers and Department of Public Health nurses should not have to apologize for upholding high standards and demanding a professional environment to teach the young and care for all of San Francisco.

Sasha Cuttler, RN Ph.D, is a nurse and activist in the SEIU Local 1021 RN chapter. He has been friends with Ruth Radetsky for more than 25 years.


Ruth is an outstanding teacher who taught our son math in middle school, now he's in a graduate program for statistics in NY. I've seen first hand the challenges she faces due to overcrowded classrooms and underfunded schools. Despite these things, I'm glad to see she remains a committed and effective public school teacher. Thanks for this article that illustrates the parallels between two of our most important public sector services, schools and hospitals that are facing similar problems. And best wishes to Ms. Radetsky for her speedy and full recovery thanks to our public health care system.

Posted by Guest on Jun. 27, 2012 @ 7:52 am

There is an error in my op-ed. Nurses are no longer being threatened with layoffs. The sentence should read: "At the same time, nurses who cared for her at SFGH continually struggle for sufficient staffing, given an increasingly acute patent population."

Posted by Sasha on Jun. 27, 2012 @ 7:01 pm

Sasha, one reason heathcare funding gets trimmed from the SF budget every year... because of SEIU's underfunded pensions. The city has to dip into the General Fund more and more each year to pay for your bloating pension costs, hence service cuts for citizens.

You have defined-benefit pension plans that guarantee 8% returns into your pensions. Pension costs (inc healthcare) now consume around 20% of all San Francisco tax revenues.

You need to be switched to defined-contribution pension plans. Then, the cuts to healthcare services at SF General will stop. Only then.

Posted by Guest on Jul. 05, 2012 @ 9:00 am

Yeah it is a great hospital. There is great facilities for treatment.

Posted by Narconon Fresh Start on Feb. 03, 2013 @ 10:55 pm

I was able to pass by and it looks great. A friend of mine also admitted her child there and got positive feedbacks not only from her but for those who have tried there also.

Posted by link2life on May. 13, 2013 @ 10:21 pm

Whenever I am searching for awesome content and ideas around the net, I always this is an awesome place for that.

Posted by überprüfen Sie hier on Jun. 18, 2013 @ 4:31 pm

Ruth Radetsk is an amazing lady, I really miss her. Hope she is doing well

Posted by Pagina on Jun. 20, 2013 @ 10:27 am

Related articles

  • The cost of shorter school days

  • Editor's notes

    When public schools can no longer afford to buy paper, it's time to reconsider the tax system

  • Cash backwards

    Ten things San Francisco should fund -- and 10 things it shouldn't -- to create a fair, equitable, and forward-thinking city budget

  • Also from this author

  • City College will appeal

    "City College neither ignored nor fought ACCJC's recommendations, as many people wish we had."

  • Transforming Pride in our schools

    It takes more than a one-time discussion or film screening to support queer youth

  • Developers should pay -- on time

    It's boom time -- a good moment to end bust-time business breaks